AI is increasingly talked about in recruitment, and with good reason. It’s very good at finding people with the right job title, and it’s now in use on both sides of the table. In the CIPD’s Resourcing and talent planning report 2026, 27% of organisations that tried to recruit said candidates were leaning too heavily on generative AI in their applications.
What AI can’t tell you is whether your brief is the right one, or whether any of the people it finds would do well in your business. In insurance and financial services hiring, that’s where most searches succeed or stall.
What AI does well
Credit where it’s due. AI can build a search in minutes, pull together research on a market and take a pile of admin off a recruiter’s desk. Our recruiters use it for all three, and the time it saves goes back into talking to people. We’ve set out exactly how Vermelo uses AI in recruitment on its own page.
The trouble starts when a list of names gets mistaken for a shortlist.
The hardest roles to fill are the ones a job title says least about
The Financial Services Skills Commission’s Annual Skills Report 2026 puts the sector’s hard-to-fill roles into two groups: the roles needed for technological change, and industry-specific roles such as underwriters, claims professionals and pricing analysts.
That second group is where a search runs out of road fastest. Two pricing analysts with the same title can be doing very different jobs, on different products, with different tools. A search will return both. Only a conversation tells you which one fits.
The market isn’t getting easier either. In the same CIPD report, 52% of organisations said competition for well-qualified people had increased over the past year, even with hiring slowing overall.
The data can be right and the brief still wrong
One of our recruiters was working with a technology business moving into insurance markets. The data said there were plenty of people with the right job title. The conversations said none of them would be a good cultural fit for a business like that.
We took what we’d heard back to the client. They adapted the brief, and a whole new group of candidates came into view that they hadn’t considered before and went on to be interviewed.
No search flagged the problem, because on paper there wasn’t one. It only showed up when people talked.
What AI tools can miss
Recruiters see this from the inside. In a UK survey published by CV-Library in April 2026, 35% of recruiters said AI tools were causing them to miss strong candidates, and 27% believed good applications were being filtered out before interview.
The regulator has looked too. When the Information Commissioner’s Office audited providers of AI recruitment tools, it made almost 300 recommendations. Its AI tools in recruitment report, published in November 2024, found that some tools could filter out candidates unfairly and that some collected more personal information than they needed.
That doesn’t make AI the problem. It does mean you should know where it sits in your process, and have a person check what it produces.
Specialist markets run on what isn’t written down
Regulated sectors like insurance and financial services are markets where people know each other, and most of them aren’t advertising that they’d consider a move. The signs that someone might be open to one are rarely public. A new manager they don’t get on with, or a team that’s about to be restructured, won’t appear on any profile. It’s often the reason a settled person starts listening.
Recruiters pick that up because they speak to the same market every week.
Your candidates are judging you too
Every approach made in your name tells a candidate something about your business. A message that reads as if nobody wrote it tells them one thing. A call from a recruiter who understands the role and your culture tells them another.
There’s a double standard worth noticing here. The CIPD found that 35% of employers try to monitor candidates’ use of AI, and three-quarters of those have rejected people for it. Candidates are entitled to hold employers to the same standard, and that first conversation is where they decide whether you’re worth their time.
Four ways to use this in your next search
Test the brief before you commit to it: Ask your recruiter what the market is saying about the role, the salary and your business before the search starts.
Ask for the reasoning as well as the shortlist: Why these people, who said no, and what did they say?
Treat “nobody suitable” as information: It may be telling you something about the brief, not the market.
Know where AI sits in your hiring: Which stages use it, and who is accountable for what comes out?
Where that leaves AI
Useful, and in its place. It clears the admin so our recruiters can have more conversations with more of the market.
Vermelo is a UK talent solutions specialist delivering RPO, Project RPO, MSP, embedded talent (RaaS), total talent and talent advisory & consultancy. Named Best Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) Business at the Global Recruiter Awards 2025. Part of the GWV Talent Solutions Group which includes Gerrard White Consulting and FlarePeople.